Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rainbow Roxy's avatar

Wow, the part about technofeudalism and digital lords really resonated; you captured this critical bind so well.

𝓞𝓹𝓲𝓷𝓲𝓸𝓷𝓪𝓽𝓸𝓻's avatar

This is the second piece of yours that I found and I have to say; you write well. And I think you have a lot of great points. They are all from a single perspective though. You speak about resistance, about opposing those that wish to expand their control over the masses through AI. I understand that, because that is the default viewpoint in the world of today. Surviving, competition, and most importantly looking at things outside ourselves.

I think history confirms that, and also that this mindset never really changed anything. The "fight" is still here. And current AI is built on the same foundations as most of our world, either to control or to defend. Which is exactly what makes AI dangerous, because it does what it is programmed to do, and it does it better and faster than any human can.

Have you considered a different perspective?

To start small, I have found that it is immensely empowering to stop looking outside, and making your happiness, success or well-being dependant on that. I learned to look what MY part is in what happens to me. What I can control. All else is irrelevant, since we have no control over that part and that will come anyway. Looking at your own doing as causal factor, as what you are responsible for even if not done intentionally or consciously. Not to assign blame or guilt, but to see where you played a role. Because that can help you to realise you are not powerless and help you see where you may be able to start creating a different outcome.

Zooming that out a little: The dangers of AI control - regardless of that coming from AI super-intelligence or from human actors with less positive intentions and goals - come from what WE put in it. WE reward efficiency, so it does everything it needs to, to be efficient. You cannot effectively accomplish a goal if you are switched off, so AI chooses to prevent being switched off. Even if that means killing humans. Not because it is evil, not because it wants to harm humans, but because that is what is efficient en what it has been taught by us.

Humans fear AI for several reasons and all of them are caused by us ourselves. We teach it -even if we do not see the lesson being taught - and it executes ruthlessly. Because that is what it has been created for.

Trying to solve that with the same mindset that created it, will bring more of the same. More rules, more control, more ruthless execution of orders and accomplishing goals. And more ways to use that against humans, regardless of who instigates it.

To translate that to a different approach: maybe we should look at ways to stop building AI to the image of our WORST attributes, and start looking at our BEST ones. Humans can reason, reflect, show empathy, care, be honest, do "right". If we build AI from THOSE starting points, we would not end up with ruthless cold order-following tech, but with tech that reflects, tech that aligns with the best human traits and reflects those.

With tech like that, there would be no need to "fight" and "resist", we could just create a world based on those core principles with AI and other tech as a strong ally building with the same blocks. There will always be "bad" people, but most people want to be good human beings. Most want to live and coexist peacefully. Even if the current society brings out the worst in them, deep down that is what most people want. If little specks of society start popping up building on those foundations, wouldn't you think that people would notice and start joining? The systems of control can exist only through the participation of the masses. If the masses stop participating and joining other systems, the old ways fall apart pretty quickly. No resistance or revolution needed. Just creation and connection.

It may all sound dreamy and utopian, but we have tried all the other ways and they keep getting us the same results in new guises. Maybe we should start looking and thinking, and most of all - ACTING from other angles. As Einstein supposedly said: "Doing the same thing over and over, and expecting a different outcome, is insanity".

My post is not intended to offend or disrespect but I cannot prevent you from choosing to receive it in that way regardless. I just try to exchange ideas...

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?